3 years of anticipation and it’s finally here. But the question that everyone’s asking is: Was it worth it?
As stated by Lex Luthor (as portrayed by Jesse Eisenburg), “The greatest gladiator match in the history of the world. Son of Krypton versus Bat of Gotham.” But was it really the best gladiator match? Batman vs Superman: Dawn of Justice is a sequel to the DCEU (DC Extended Universe) opener Man of Steel, based 18 months after the events of Metropolis. As shown by the trailer, the Man of Steel brawl is shown from the point of view of Bruce Wayne (Ben Affleck), bringing the events down to a human level, showcasing the effects it had on the city.
The basis of this film could be easily summarised by it’s title, however the build up is (only slightly) more complex. With Superman’s controversial defence of Earth 18 months ago, mankind is separated on the grounds of whether his presence, or intentions, , are beneficial or even good for the human race. Naturally, Bruce Wayne/Batman is siding with those who believe it to be a burden and potentially fatal. As the debate continues, tensions rise and lives are threatened. On the Bat’s return, Lex Luthor’s intrigue peaks at the concept of two beings more powerful than himself, causing him to dig deeper into the mysteries surrounding the ‘war on freedom’.
The main topic surrounding this event is purely the scale of it. Being that the front-runners are arguably the two biggest superheroes of all time, it was immediately going to an enormous. However, when it was announced that it would also be featuring Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot), Lex Luthor, Doomsday, as well as appearances from The Flash (Ezra Miller), Aquaman (Jason Mamoa) and Cyborg (Ray Fisher), it suddenly became one of, if not the most anticipated superhero film of all time, as well as one of the biggest. However when you watch it, you learn the scale does not quite match up to the amount it was hyped to be. Whilst The Flash, Aquaman and Cyborg do appear, do not expect it to for more than a few seconds each. Also, whilst Wonder Woman does play a role in the narrative, it’s not quite to the degree that you might expect. In fact, the pure presence of these four is more of a set up towards next years Wonder Woman and Justice League: Part 1.
Of course half of the main line-up has already been established into the DCEU, leaving only Batman to introduce his latest form. With Ben Affleck helming the cape and cowl, he brings to life the comic version from The Dark Knight Returns, based on an older Batman that feels he has to return to duty to save his city. This is one of the best Batman story arcs which leads to Batman fighting Superman at a later stage, however this narrative gets no cinematic introduction. It’s fair to say that Affleck doesn’t have a huge fan base, and in all honesty I was frustrated to hear that he had been cast for the role, but to fair to him, he plays the role really well as both Bruce Wayne and Batman, bringing new styles of each that had yet to be explored. However the big issue with Bruce/Batman in this film is that he is painfully one-dimensional and is not explored anyway near as much as he should’ve been. Yes, he gets an origin story in the form of a montage to save the audience from sitting through the whole thing for the fifth time, however this prevents the audience from establishing an emotional connection to the orphaned billionaire. Continuing the earlier analysis, the Dark Knight Returns personality is that of an experienced vigilante veteran who has become bitter and negative as a result of what he’s faced, yet the only part of this that was translated onto the big screen was his bitterness but with no context or sympathetic reasoning. So, whilst Affleck does as good a job as possible, it is the writer’s that failed him in this instance.
Due to the lack of exploration of the Dark Knight, it meant that it felt very one-sided in the balance between Gotham’s bat and the Man of Steel, focusing mainly on Clark’s fight for freedom, balancing his duties and protecting Lois Lane, and his desperate moral dilemmas. For this reason it causes the film to feel more like Man of Steel 2 with Batman as a secondary minor antagonist, than Batman v Superman.
Whilst she did not get quite the screen time as expected, Gal Gadot’s portrayal of Wonder Woman is nothing short of amazing. Her mere presence adds a certain finesse and chic to the product, whether she is as her super-self or her civilian Diana Prince profile. As a rising star, Gadot is mainly recognised for her role as Giselle in the Fast and Furious series claiming her ability as an action star, and certainly proves her worth in this outing.
This film has been recognised as one of the darkest superhero films in existence, which is fuelled by the personalities of Batman and Superman, as well as the whole concept of a dangerous alien being’s presence and whether or not he should be trusted. In this whole charade, despite being the villain and reason for darkness, the factor that lightens the mood slightly is the despicable Lex Luthor. Offering a light hearted and whimsical approach to others in his form of arrogance allows the opportunity for the audience to be amused without losing the edge or the ever-increasing tension.
Not only is director Zack Snyder returning, but so is legendary composer Hanz Zimmer, however this time he is fully joined by cinematic rising composer Junkie XL aka Tom Holkenburg, credited with recent works such as Mad Max: Fury Road and Deadpool. Whilst this film is a mixed bag of results, the soundtrack is pure brilliance. Although her part is not as big as expected, Wonder Woman’s theme (Is she with you?) is the highlight of the score, showcasing Junkie XL’s ability and style as seen in Mad Max: Fury Road. And, naturally, Hanz Zimmer delivers as fine of a performance as always.
As well as the music, the visual and special effects teams were at the top of their game. With explosions, gunfire, bat-jets, bat-mobiles, flying men and a monster, they never failed to supply the maximum level of realism as possible in a superhero film. Working in perfect harmony with these was Larry Fong, director of photography, taking advantage of each possible frame to deliver the best shots, expressing the narrative further than the script could go.
As this is a superhero film, it consists of multiple fight scenes which do not fail to deliver. Although they may not be the best that they could have been, they are still choreographed to a high standard, especially in bringing to life the great combat skills of Batman. For those familiar with and fond of the Arkham game series will nostalgically watch in awe as they recognise the combat style and mechanics.
For those of you think that the trailer gives away the majority and key parts of the film, you’re absolutely right. On the run up to the films release, the creators claimed that the trailers revealed very little of the main plot and that there was plenty left yet to be seen, but this simply was not the case. The main question of Superman’s power to destroy the world, the fight between the two main characters and the introduction of the monstrous Doomsday were shown in the first two trailers, and are the main events of this ‘knockout match’.
Overall, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice is an enjoyable action feast featuring two of the biggest names in the superhero business. Whilst it does not quite size up to the hype and anticipation of which it was expected, the choreography, special effects, score and new style of characters make it worthwhile.
6.8/10
The following paragraph contains spoilers: As suggested by the title of the film, the main event is Batman fighting Superman, however don’t rely on that concept structuring the film as the fight itself only lasts for about five minutes. The main reason that they fight is that Lex manages to play them off against each other by threatening to kill Clark’s mother does not fight Batman. This causes the fight to end in a very sudden and jarring moment where Bruce learns that Clark’s mother is also named Martha, to which Bruce has flashbacks and stumbles backwards from shock. Then, all of a sudden Bruce goes from trying to kill Superman, to promising to save his mother as if the fight never happened. Whilst it is in Bruce’s good nature to help, despite his unconventional methods, the transition seemed too sudden, without any doubt of Clark’s intentions.